Martin Goodman reviewed Shlomo Sand’s Invention of the Jewish People for the TLS (review not online) but neglected to mention that he was criticised in the book.
Shlomo Sand then replied and the TLS published his letter last week.
The least one might expect from an honest book reviewer is that he inform his readers when he is himself the subject of criticism of the book under review.
Now Martin Goodman has responded. You can read his letter here.
See the website for Shlomo Sand’s book here.